Review: “Mistborn”

Background: When Robert Jordan died I was surprised to hear the decision regarding finishing up his final novel, Memories of Light, was made so quickly. It fell to Brandon Sanderson, a young writer I had never heard of. Fast-forward a year or so later, and after stumbling upon his insightful blog, I took up reading his books. His first novel, Elantris, was a nice little piece of one and done fantasy, but not groundbreaking. His follow up, Mistborn is the first of a trilogy that thunders onto the fantasy landscape with such refreshing force that its echoes are likely being felt by readers and authors everywhere.

Setting: The overarching premise of Mistborn is that the great hero of legend, the very same character that inevitably ends up being central to novels, fantasy cinema, and Dungeons and Dragons game simply fails. Instead of a peaceful free world, the immortal tyranny of god-king Lord Ruler presides over a blasted land where ashfalls are as common as rainfall. The nobility clamps down on the peasant-class skaa while magic is derived through the ingestion of certain metals. There are eight common metals, each of which grants a fantastic ability, but very few can use even one metal. The rare few that can master all eight are called Mistborn and highly sought after commodities amongst the powerful. To say it lightly, the entire premise of the book is masterfully conceived. From the inversion of normal fantasy to the detailed, but uncomplicated, system of magic, this is truly a breath of fresh air.

Story: The dismal failure of prior revolts against Lord Ruler causes a unique spin on the traditional fight against tyranny that so commonly populates fantasy literature. Lacking any idealist hopefuls, it falls to an incredibly talented group of thieves to plan the ultimate caper to topple the system. To say that their motivation is unusual (money, revenge and boredom) or that their odds seem particularly hopeless (only one of their number is even remotely powerful enough to stand up to the Lord Ruler’s main henchmen) is an understatement. Without giving away too much, I can say that for a planned trilogy this book has an immensely satisfying conclusion and a great plot that manages to combine some of the best elements of fantasy, caper based movies (Ocean’s 11, The Sting), and Matrix/Anime infused kung fu sensibilities. It sounds like a strange brew, and perhaps it is, but it really works.

Overall: A. (CRITICAL HIT!) If you’re a fan of the genre, chances are you have read Wheel of Time anyway, so you may as well pick up this excellent novel to get a preview of the style to expect. As if that wasn’t good enough, Mistborn has been priced down to priced down to $4.99… all of which will be rebated if you end up buying the trilogy’s hardcover when it comes out in October. Highly Recommended!


  1. I just finished Mistborn two days ago, and Elantris over the summer, and I agree with your review. In fact, I’ve been going over how I could introduce Allomancer as a class in 4e…I just thought it was such a fresh look at magic that I think it’d be interesting to throw it into the game — keep people on their toes, at least.

    Anyway, Sanderson’s main characters are detailed and driven by motivations I can believe, and his secondary characters are also far more ‘alive’ than in most books. I felt this way about both books — the secondary characters develop throughout the story, and even surprise the reader from time to time, instead of just being “the clever guy” or “the strong guy” — they arent’ cardboard cut-outs there to fill in the gaps between the main cast.

    I’ll definitely read the other books in the series, and recommend them to anyone who wants good, original fantasy.

  2. …and added to my library queue.

    I’m running a game soon where the characters have a shot of taking down a corrupt government. This book sounds like it might give me some ideas.

    Avaril´s last post: Of all things Mega

  3. Very interesting. I hadn’t heard of Sanderson either, but now I’m intrigued. I’ll have to find a copy and check it out. Sounds extremely cool.

  4. Ravenhairedbeauty68504 says:

    I have read two books in the trilogy and will begin reading the 3rd tonight. I have enjoyed the Mistborn Trilogy greatly! There have been moments during my read that I have been unable to put the books down…or go to bed! The idea of characters coming from a lowly station in life to morph into the most powerful “Allomancer” or “Hero of Ages”, or the fact that she is female was a wonderful concept. Anyone who loves a quest like story with lots of action and highly developed characters will certainly inhale these stories and keep them in their own “favorite” personal libraries! I know I will…


  1. […] Accessibility and plot structure suffer a bit as a result. While not easy to pick up as a book like Mistborn, it’s a project committing to the series, but well worth the […]